|
|
|
The “Buy America” Sellout
Spending public money locally is not the problem – the WTO Government Procurement Agreement is
Profiting from municipal frustration, and exaggerating the impact of “Buy American” policies on Canadian companies, the Harper government and provinces signed a multi-pronged government procurement agreement with the United States on February 16 that will see provincial and local spending powers permanently limited under World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. In return for fleeting access to a sliver of the original $280 billion worth of U.S. stimulus money for infrastructure, Canada’s provinces are to be included in the WTO’s Government Procurement Agreement (GPA) – a plurilateral contract signed by only 40 countries that forbids listed national and subnational governments and agencies from favouring domestic content or considering other local benefits when spending public money.
This is a big deal. Canada’s provinces have been reluctant to sign onto the GPA precisely because there was and is still no way to guarantee reciprocal access to the U.S. procurement market. While some areas, including urban transit and energy-related projects are currently excluded, the provinces are on a slippery slope as this agreement goes forward. That’s because Canada has committed to continuing talks toward an even bigger, permanent procurement agreement with the United States, potentially under NAFTA. Also, the provinces and cities are under intense pressure from the European Union, through ongoing free trade negotiations, to open up even more provincial and municipal spending on goods, services and construction to European companies. European service providers, for example, see Canada’s public services, which are delivered provincially and municipally, as a potential money maker through privatization. The GPA offers trade tools to help make that happen.
While Prime Minister Harper refuses to renegotiate NAFTA to improve labour and environmental protections, he has essentially done what amounts to the same thing as reworking the deal by binding municipalities and provinces to trade rules curbing their powers over local economies. And he did it while Parliament was prorogued, with no plans to let our elected politicians study the deal to see if it’s worth it. Local procurement is not the problem. In fact, it is one of the last vestiges of public control over how local communities develop and grow, and an important tool in growing their economies. We cannot let this new agreement stand without a fight.
We believe that governments have a right and a duty to use public procurement as a tool for economic development, environmental protection and job creation. Therefore, we oppose the expansion of “free trade” deals to encompass more public procurement.
Read more »
Resources
ACTION ALERT
MEDIA
- [14-Sep-11] Harper should let US procurement deal expire and choose 'Buy Canadian'
- [11-Feb-10] Council of Canadians and CUPE release leaked ‘Buy American’ agreement
- [10-Feb-10] Walk away from ‘Buy American’ deal, urges Maude Barlow in open letter to premiers
- [10-Feb-10] Council of Canadians, CUPE, & CAW to release leaked copy of Canada-US "Buy America" deal
- OP-ED: Don't celebrate this deal, Ottawa Citizen, Maude Barlow and Stuart Trew, February 6, 2010
- [11-Feb-10] Council of Canadians and CUPE release leaked ‘Buy American’ agreement
- [10-Feb-10] Walk away from ‘Buy American’ deal, urges Maude Barlow in open letter to premiers
- [05-Feb-10] Harper says Bye to Buy Local
- [30-Sept-09] Show us the "Buy American" deal before signing it, demands Council of Canadians
- No payoff for premiers in `Buy American' fix, By Stuart Trew and and Blair Redlin, The Star, August 7, 2009
- [05-Aug-09] Federal government, Premiers have no mandate to renegotiate NAFTA by stealth, says Council of Canadians
- Losing sight of the economic forest for 'Buy American' trees, By Blair Redlin (CUPE), Vancouver Sun, July 14, 2009
- Are EU trade talks behind the pressure to end local procurement? By Blair Redlin (CUPE), June 12, 2009
- [10-June-09] “Buy America” boogeyman no reason for provinces to renounce powers over procurement
- Municipalities want say in future trade talks,
CUPE, June 6, 2009
MULTIMEDIA
BLOGS
- Buy American, Trade Blog by Stuart Trew, Trade Campaigner at the Council of Canadians
- Trade and Buy American, Campaign Blog by Brent Patterson, Director of Campaigns and Communications at the Council of Canadians
REPORTS/PRESENTATIONS/LETTERS/WEBSITES
- ‘Canada’s Buy American Plan? Buy American’, Canadian Perspectives, Spring 2010
- CAW comments to the Standing Committee on International Trade (CIIT) Re: Buy American trade deal, Angelo DiCaro, Jenny J.H. Ahn, April 1, 2010
- Submission to the Standing Committee on International Trade (CIIT) Re: Canada-US Agreement on Government Procurement, Steven Shrybman, March 23, 2010
- Opening remarks to the Standing Committee on International Trade Re: Canada-U.S. Trade Relations,
Scott Sinclair, Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, March 16, 2010
- Presentation
to the Standing Committee on International Trade Re: Canada-U.S. Trade Relations, Teresa Healy, Canadian Labour Congress March 16, 2010
- Buy American Sell-out: Giving Away Canadian Procurement Sovereignty, A new report by Scott Sinclair for the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, November 2009
- Sample letter: Buy American policy. Ontario Bye to Buy Local trade tour handout, October 2009.
- Say bye to buy local - A primer on trade deals impacting Ontario, CUPE Ontario and the Council of Canadians, October 2009
- Buy Canadian – Build Communities,
Municipal council resolution supported by the Canadian Auto Workers
- Making Buy America Work for Canada,
United Steelworkers campaign website
- Legal opinion on NAFTA/WTO compatibility of CAW’s Buy Canadian campaign,
By Steven Shrybman for the CAW
- Depression, Not Protectionism, Is What’s Killing Trade,
By Jim Stanford, CAW economist
- 'Buy American' policies not all bad news for Canada,
By Ken Neuman, national director, United Steelworkers Canada
- In defence of “Buy America”, By Erin Weir, economist, United Steelworkers Canada

|