fbpx
Skip to content

NEWS: Canada, EU reach MOU on hormone-treated beef

Reuters reports that, “Canada has gained duty-free access to the European Union for a 20,000-tonne annual quota of beef, Canada’s agriculture and trade ministers said on Tuesday. The access is worth about C$10 million ($9.8 million) annually, the ministers said.”

The article also notes, “Canada and the European Commission also have finalized a memorandum of understanding that sets a path toward resolving the long-standing World Trade Organization dispute between Canada and the European Union on beef hormones, the ministers said.”

As we noted in a July 2010 campaign blog:

One of the Harper government’s main objectives in the Canada-European Union Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement negotiations appears to be ending European Union restrictions on the import of hormone-treated beef from Canada.

HEALTH RISKS
There has been strong opposition in Europe to hormone-treated beef due to its associated health risks. Studies indicate that for women it can make them more susceptible to breast cancer and other cancers, for pregnant women it can affect the development of male fetuses, and for men it can lead to an increased risk of prostate cancer. More on that in this London Daily Mail news article from 2006, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-393666/Alarm-beef-link-breast-cancer.html.

More on the health impacts can also be read on the Beyond Factory Farming website at http://beyondfactoryfarming.org/get-informed/health/hormones.

TRADE TIME LINE
1980s – the European Union bans the use of growth-promoting hormones and the import of meat treated with these hormones
1996 – Canada and the United States challenge this ban at the World Trade Organization
1998 – the WTO Appellate Body finds that the EU ban was not consistent with parts of the WTO Agreement on Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures in that their scientific risk assessments were not sufficiently specific
1999 – the WTO grants Canada and the US the authorization to impose import duty sanctions on the EU
2003 – a new EU Directive is adopted against the import of meat treated with hormones and notified the WTO
2004 – the EU files a request for consultations with Canada and the US asserting the import duty sanctions should be dropped given the scientific evidence in the EU Directive
2008 – a WTO panel finds that the EU has violated WTO rules by maintaining a definitive ban on one hormone and continuing to impose provisional bans on five other hormones.

To read more about this trade dispute (and the health risks associated with hormone-treated beef), please go to the Canadian Health Coalition website at http://www.healthcoalition.ca/hormones.html.

CERT
In a twist to this almost 20-year-old dispute, a recent Canwest News Service article reported that Jason Langrish, executive director of the Canada Europe Round Table, “said the proposed (CETA’s) quota is large enough to make it profitable for Canadian ranchers to raise hormone-free beef.”

As noted in our fact sheet, “The Canada-EU Business Roundtable (CERT), a business lobby providing much of the support and input on priorities for the free trade negotiations, suggests a policy of mutual recognition of standards. That doesn’t mean Canada will follow Europe in areas such as the regulation of toxic chemicals, where the EU has developed a much stronger system than in North America. It means that European jurisdictions may be asked to turn a blind eye to weaker Canadian regulations and vice versa. Mutual recognition is preferred by business groups because it means that weaker standards in one jurisdiction cannot be used to justify blocking products from entering markets in the other jurisdiction.”

COUNCIL OF CANADIANS
In 1999, the Council of Canadians calls on the federal government to re-evaluate the use of growth hormones in Canadian beef and to stop penalizing the EU for trying to protect the health of their citizens. More on that at http://canadians.org/media/trade/1999/13-May-99.html.

We will continue to track the issue of hormone-treated beef in relation to the Canada-EU CETA talks.
Council of Canadians analysis on CETA can be read at http://canadians.org/CETA.

The campaign blog is at http://canadians.org/campaignblog/?p=4298. Today’s Reuters article is at http://ca.reuters.com/article/topNews/idCATRE6AM3I720101123.