The issue of chlorinated chicken has become a major issue of concern in the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) ‘free trade’ talks between the United States and the European Union. EU Observer explains, “US poultry producers have fewer sanitary demands on conditions for chicken, because once the chickens are slaughtered, they are dipped in a bleaching solution which kills all germs and bacteria. The EU has banned imports of this kind of meat.”
Last October, an environment committee report for the European Parliament flagged this as a concern. Then in February, EU Observer noted, “A top EU official has sought to allay German fears about the US being able to export bleached chicken … to Europe once a free trade pact comes into force.” And France 24 has reported, “Chicken washed in chlorine … could be making their way into European supermarkets under a free trade agreement being negotiated between the US and EU.”
While European activists have rightly focused on this issue within TTIP, should similar concerns be expressed about CETA, the Canada-European Union Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement?
Yes, poultry was excluded in CETA, but Health Canada says of our regulations, “Poultry carcasses and parts are also permitted to be dipped, sprayed, or washed with water containing 20-50 mg total available chlorine/L (CFIA, 2004) or up to 10 mg/L for total available chlorine as hypochlorous acid, provided that treatment is followed by a rinse with potable water.”
But if not chicken (for now), what about chlorinated beef?
Exporting more Canadian beef to Europe was a top demand of Canadian negotiators in the CETA talks. And CETA means that Canadian beef producers will be able sell an additional 50,000 tonnes of beef to Europe, which in Canada is washed and processed using chlorinated water. Our regulations state, “Beef must then be followed by a rinse with potable water or a similar appropriate measure to ensure that residues resulting from treatment are negligible (CFIA, 2004).”
It’s also notable that the regulatory cooperation chapter in CETA inserts the Canadian beef industry more into the European regulatory process. CETA would also establish a separate ‘Joint Management Committee for Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures’, including plant and animal safety rules and food regulation. That Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures chapter also includes sections on equivalency of rules which could serve to erode the more stringent European food safety standards.
It should be highlighted that the EU appears to be heading down this path already. In February 2013, before the TTIP negotiations began, EurActiv reported, “The European Union [has] dropped its ban on … beef washed in lactic acid [which] is meant to show the Europeans are serious about a [TTIP] deal. The United States Mission to the European Union Foreign Agricultural Service notes, “Commission Regulation (EU) No 101/2013, published in the Official Journal on February 5, 2013, allows the application of lactic acid as a pathogen reduction treatment (PRT) on beef carcasses, half-carcasses and beef quarters in the slaughterhouse. …[This] will allow U.S. beef exporters to better take advantage of EU beef quotas, worth $700 million…”